Comments

To Keep Our Senses Open — 4 Comments

  1. You three have certainly made me feel that sharing this writing has helped you in your endeavors. Thank you for letting me know the particular ways in which the essay has helped and for giving me fresh eyes with which to see the work.

  2. Apart from the poignancy of this piece–which is palpable–my favorite thing Sheila did was all the ways that she conjured up Seth by linking him to what she saw in the environment. I loved how the undulating waves made her think of the backs of dolphins and whales which made her think of the orca totem Seth made. I loved how the tugboat out in the harbor looked like a furry creature from a children’s book which made her think of the children Seth would’ve had. My favorite connection was the white collared Vaux. The bird with its white collar and black plummage becomes associated with images of Seth in black pants and white shirt. For me, this was one of the most powerful parts of the whole piece! I also loved the poem and the wrenching feeling of loss this artifact from the past created. I liked the dramatic contrast between the poem written when Seth was alive and the essay itself written after he’s gone. I loved the use of “sliding into the lap” in the poem. What I learned from this piece was the effectiveness of using aspects of the natural world (such as the white collared vaux) to conjure up a person. I also thought the piece was an
    effective example of the use of present and past events with a good and clear transition between the two (the old poem within the new essay being particularly effective). I certainly feel encouraged to try some of these techniques!

  3. Sheila, thank you for this poignant, beautiful excerpt. It was a pleasure–and heart-wrenching–to read it again. Throughout the book, you capture Seth’s personality so well that I feel I knew him. And you also eloquently capture your own grief and restoration after his death. I can’t imagine how difficult it must have been to, first, go through that experience, and then to write about it. Thanks you for having the courage to do so.

    This article came at a good time for me. My mother has suffered a massive stroke, and though she is doing as well as can be expected, she is greatly debilitated and won’t be going home again. Fortunately, her resilience and sense of humor are intact. She is still my mom, although in a somewhat different form. I’m feeling a kind of ambiguous loss as I deal with these changes and am missing her terribly since we can’t talk on the phone any longer and she’s too far away to see very often. Reading your excerpt today has given me some encouragement and ideas about how I might write about this. I know that will help. Thank you.

  4. In every possible way, Sheila has shared not just her loss and her grief with us all, but she has given us access to the very object of her endless love. In the most profound way, she presents Seth alive and tactile, lovely and precious, palpable in her words. That her talent gives voice to coming to terms with such a loss does nothing to disguise the real driving force: the sublime love of a mother for her child, a love that reaches into the very heart of death to breathe his life for all of us. Writing on my own countless losses, what has worked for me is to give myself permission to look straight into the blackness in order to see light. My own writing is painful to read, even for me, but putting it all out there, holding nothing back, has brought such freedom and healing that I can hardly believe it. More and more unencumbered, less and less mourning my losses, my whole perspective has changed, about who I am and how I got this way. Writers like Shiela Bender are great roadsigns on the path. I am so grateful.

Leave a Reply

HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>