↓
 

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real

Community Writing Resource

  • Home
  • About
    • About Sheila Bender
    • Videos
    • Testimonials
    • Contact Sheila
  • Media
  • Archives
    • Article Library
      • Full Article Library
      • Instructional Exercises
      • Literary Gallery
      • Reading for Writing
      • Revisions – Sample Successes
      • Sheila Bender On Writing
      • The Working Writer
      • Writing Makes a Difference
    • Writing It Real Contributors
    • Audio Interviews
  • Books by Sheila
    • View My Books
  • Classes
    • Online Classes
    • Live Seminars
  • One-On-One Services
    • Zoom or Telephone Consults
    • Custom Tutorials
    • Book-length Manuscript Evaluation 
    • Development and Line Editing

Category Archives: Revisions – Sample Successes

Revising Older Poems — It’s Never Too Late to Take Another Look

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on April 18, 2019 by Sheila BenderApril 18, 2019

[This article appeared first in April, 2012.] April is National Poetry Month. Feeling a little badly that I hadn’t started new poems to celebrate the month, I decided to look through old files in a computer folder labeled “archived poems.” … Continue reading →

Posted in Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2019 | 2 Replies

Taking Inspiration from Allen Ginsberg’s Poems to Have My Say

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on November 8, 2018 by Sheila BenderNovember 9, 2018

Tuesday, as I waited for election returns, I thought of Allen Ginsberg’s poem “Howl,” written in 1955, so full of despair at what he had seen around him. I wondered what I would howl when I found out whether or … Continue reading →

Posted in Instructional Exercises, Revisions - Sample Successes, The Working Writer, WIR2014, WIR2018 | Tagged writing exercises, writing inspiration, Writing Poetry | 2 Replies

Moving an Essay Toward Completion — Pam Robinson’s “Table of Plenty”

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on September 6, 2018 by Pam RobinsonSeptember 6, 2018

Pam Robinson’s entry into the fall 2011 Writing It Real contest is an essay about her memories of her mother’s cooking and life on a farm. As I spend time harvesting onions, potatoes, tomatoes, cucumbers, various beans, Asian pears and … Continue reading →

Posted in Contest Winner, Reading for Writing, Revisions - Sample Successes, Sheila Bender On Writing, WIR2018 | Tagged contest winner, personal essay, revising writing | 6 Replies

To Follow Your Words, Not Your Keys, Home

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on July 12, 2018 by Cyndi LloydJuly 12, 2018

Years ago, a poet friend of mine, Jim Mitsui, ended a poem with an image of people “following their keys home.” That image has lingered with me as a lesson about what the writing life saves us from, which is … Continue reading →

Posted in Revisions - Sample Successes, Sheila Bender On Writing, The Working Writer, WIR2018 | Tagged revising writing, Trusting Images, writing exercises, Writing Poetry | 7 Replies

A Revision Success Story: Developing “The Longest Walk” by Arla Shephard Bull

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on May 20, 2016 by Arla Shephard BullApril 18, 2021

Writing It Real member Arla Shephard Bull worked back and forth with me on developing an essay that was important to her to write. She had decided to use the third person as a way of distancing herself enough to … Continue reading →

Posted in Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2015, WIR2016 | Tagged personal essay, revising writing, women's voices | 3 Replies

Before and After: Shaping a Personal Essay Using the 3-Step Response Method

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on May 6, 2015 by Marjorie FordMay 13, 2015

The back and forth you’ll read this week on the development of an essay-in-progress demonstrates the power of my three-step response method for helping writers revise. Years ago, Marjorie Ford sent me an essay-in-progress that she was having trouble developing to her satisfaction for meeting an upcoming anthology … Continue reading →

Posted in Revisions - Sample Successes, Sheila Bender On Writing, WIR2015 | Tagged personal essay, revising writing, Sheila Bender, Trusting Images | 2 Replies

How a Personal Essay Becomes Fully Manifest

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on September 24, 2014 by Betty ShaferSeptember 25, 2014

Betty Shafer asked me to read an essay about losing her adult son. It had been a year since she began the essay following an emotional author reading I gave at the Colorado Mountain Writer’s Conference she attended in June … Continue reading →

Posted in Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2014 | Tagged personal essay, revising writing, trust your writing | 1 Reply

If You Write Prose, You Can Write Poetry

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on September 18, 2013 by Sheila BenderSeptember 18, 2013

A few years ago, Kathy Lockwood, one of my distance learning students, was having trouble writing poems because she was moving. She had to clean out and reduce her belongings, pack things up and move on, though she and her … Continue reading →

Posted in Instructional Exercises, Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2013 | Tagged Trusting Images, writing advice, Writing Poetry | Leave a reply

The Work of an Opening — To Achieve an Engaging, Smooth and Useful Beginning

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on August 28, 2013 by Julaina M. KleistAugust 28, 2013

Julaina Kleist-Corwin’s story is our third place winner in the spring/summer 2013 Writing It Real writing contest. Guest judge Terry Persun wrote to us that he chose the story because he liked the pacing and grew “to know the characters, … Continue reading →

Posted in Literary Gallery, Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2013 | Tagged contest winner, contest winning essay, Revision in prose writing, writing advice, Writing Fiction, Writing Scenes | 4 Replies

Expect It In The Casino by Diane C. Drury, Our Third Place Winner

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on October 17, 2012 by Diane DruryDecember 18, 2012

The recent Writing It Real contest provided the opportunity for people to write about the world around them, send in a draft, receive my responses for help in revising, and then re-enter a revision for our final judge, Betsy Howell. … Continue reading →

Posted in Literary Gallery, Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2012 | Tagged contest winner, Writing Poetry | Leave a reply

Accepting the Personal in the Personal Essay

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on October 4, 2012 by Mary Ann PayneOctober 4, 2012

Accepting the Personal in the Personal Essay In this week’s “Revision Diary,” I am offering an account of how writer Mary Ann Payne and I worked from a journal entry to a finished essay.  Mary Ann told me that often … Continue reading →

Posted in Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2012 | 1 Reply

Hula Girl

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on October 4, 2012 by Jan HallidayOctober 4, 2012

On a cool, partly sunny Port Townsend summer day, I met with a writer’s group whose members have continued to gather and respond to each other’s writing years after meeting each other in a five-week essay writing course. After a … Continue reading →

Posted in Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2012 | 4 Replies

Boating to Breakfast: Evolution of Mary Langer Thompson’s First-Place Winning Poem

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on September 26, 2012 by Mary ThompsonDecember 18, 2012

In our spring/summer Writing It Real contest, writers and poets sent in writing inspired by the world around them. That’s a broad topic as we might be looking at the world close up and intimately or from afar. In selecting … Continue reading →

Posted in Literary Gallery, Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2012 | Tagged contest winner, Trusting Images, Writing Poetry | 2 Replies

Editing Your Story: Tight Editing Helps Writers Find the Gold

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on October 13, 2011 by Sheila BenderNovember 28, 2011

Finished writing has to sound natural, but it isn’t “just like talking.” When we talk, our listeners are aware that what we are saying is our story. As authors, we send our words out into the world without our gestures … Continue reading →

Posted in Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2011 | 2 Replies

Shall I Fly Away?

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on June 9, 2011 by Inez HolgerNovember 28, 2011

We are pleased to post our third-place winning essay in the Writing It Real Winter 2011 contest. Inez Holger’s original entry into the contest sparked a few questions from me about where I wanted to know just a little bit … Continue reading →

Posted in Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2011 | 13 Replies

Cheating Death

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on May 12, 2011 by Mary Ann van BeurenNovember 28, 2011

Contest judge Janice Eidus chose “Cheating Death” as a winner in our winter Writing It Real writing contest, saying, “I admire how in succinct fashion the writer authentically captures the painful process of grieving, including the step of moving on.” … Continue reading →

Posted in Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2011 | 4 Replies

Five Stars: An Adventure in Amatory Dining

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on May 5, 2011 by Alice LoweNovember 28, 2011

Our guest judge, Janice Eidus, wrote of Alice’s essay: “I admire how the writer uses food as a romantic metaphor in such an original way. Also, the ending is truly an ‘inevitable surprise.’” This week, we share Alice Lowe’s finished … Continue reading →

Posted in Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2011 | 6 Replies

Body Language: A Traditional Turkish Bath Experience

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on February 4, 2011 by Sheila BenderOctober 17, 2011

This week we are posting the third of our three winners in the fall 2010 Writing It Real contest. Rhonda Wiley-Jones has been a traveler since her teen years and, it seems from her essay, has learned to make good … Continue reading →

Posted in Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2011 | 4 Replies

“In The Fragments” by Sindee Ernst

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on July 8, 2010 by Sheila BenderOctober 17, 2011

When guest judge Anna Quinn selected Sindee Ernst’s essay as our Winter No-Contest Contest winner, she wrote, “A wonderful piece. Writer uses specific sensory detail beautifully to evoke feelings of leaving one’s childhood home and discovering another. Strong ending.” Sindee … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2010 | 2 Replies

“The Cheetah, The Spider and Me” by Gloria Orlando Ives

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on July 1, 2010 by Sheila BenderOctober 17, 2011

So often as writers we know we have captured something in our drafts and have brought the work as far as we can at the moment, but sometimes we miss seeing what our writing is leading us toward. That’s when … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2010 | Leave a reply

“He Was Surprised And So Was I” by Meg Hannah House

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on June 24, 2010 by Sheila BenderOctober 17, 2011

Meg Hannah House won third place in this winter’s Writing It Real No-Contest Contest for her personal essay “He Was Surprised And So Was I”. Our contest was designed so that entrants wrote in response to words they came across … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2010 | 3 Replies

The Annual Christmas Dress Shopping Trip

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on December 10, 2009 by Sheila BenderOctober 17, 2011

This week, I am sharing my developmental editing responses to another Honorable Mention essay in our Summer 2009 No-Contest Contest. You’ll see Karen B. Call’s original contest entry, my written responses to her work and then her revised essay. You’ll … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2009 | Leave a reply

Tenderness and Meat Loaf

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on December 3, 2009 by Sheila BenderOctober 17, 2011

Continuing in our revision diary category posts, this week we are sharing an essay by Jack Shea, one of two essays that our guest judge Brenda Miller chose as honorable mention in our recent contest. My developmental editing comments inserted … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2009 | 1 Reply

The Berry Patch

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on November 26, 2009 by Sheila BenderOctober 17, 2011

Reading the draft Joyce sent to us for the Fall 2009 Writing It Real No-Contest Contest and the tweaked version, you’ll see an example of the importance of polish editing. Although an essay might be “all there” on the page, … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2009 | Leave a reply

Porch Swings

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on November 19, 2009 by Sheila BenderOctober 17, 2011

In this article, we present Lisa Kee’s winning essay from our Fall 2009 No-Contest Contest. Each entrant submitted an essay, which I read and responded to. All entrants had the opportunity to revise their essays after reading my comments and … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2009 | Leave a reply

Julie Barker’s First Place Essay Overturned

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on November 12, 2009 by Sheila BenderOctober 17, 2011

In this article, we present Julie Barker’s winning essay from our Fall 2009 No-Contest Contest. Each entrant submitted an essay, which I read and responded to. All entrants had the opportunity to revise their essays after reading my comments and … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2009 | 1 Reply

“Walking to School” by Nancy Kane

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on June 11, 2009 by Nancy KaneOctober 17, 2011

“Walking to School” is an essay that is very close to being completely satisfying. I want to share the essay and the comments I sent Nancy in our recent No-Contest Contest to provide the experience of workshopping an essay using … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2009 | Leave a reply

Incognito Street: How Travel Made Me A Writer by Barbara Sjoholm

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on September 6, 2007 by Sheila BenderOctober 31, 2011

Barbara Sjoholm‘s memoir in essays, Incognito Street: How Travel Made Me a Writer, Seal Press, 2006, evokes a 1970s-style Bohemian travel life and will arouse memories in many readers. Those who knew they wanted to write when they were young … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2007 | Leave a reply

Getting to the Details

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on July 20, 2006 by Sheila BenderOctober 31, 2011

I am fortunate to have the opportunity to work with people in developing their essays. Writing It Real subscriber Beth Einstein entered our spring essay contest and recently took me up on my offer to work with her essay for … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2006 | Leave a reply

The House of the Seven Gambles – Revised

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on June 8, 2006 by Sheila BenderOctober 31, 2011

When I judged Mary Ann Payne’s essay submitted for Writing It Real’s first 2006 personal essay contest as our runner up, I wrote to her with comments about her ending and ideas for strengthening it.   Here is the essay she … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2006 | Leave a reply

Relying on the Lyric

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on January 19, 2006 by Sheila BenderOctober 31, 2011

On July 8, 2004, I posted an instructional exercise article, “Put Summer on the Page,” encouraging writers to use the opening of Ray Bradbury’s novel Dandelion Wine for inspiration in writing their own memories. Recently, I worked with Michelle Vanstrom … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2006 | Leave a reply

Medicare Essay

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on March 24, 2005 by Marlee MillmanSeptember 26, 2011

This year Marlee Millman wrote an essay to read to her family and friends who were gathering to celebrate her 65th birthday in her hometown of Chicago. She was excited and wanted to have a speech prepared. She emailed me: … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes | Leave a reply

An Inland Navy

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on November 25, 2004 by Sheila BenderOctober 27, 2011

In last week’s article I reviewed Natalie Goldberg’s The Great Failure: A Bartender, a Monk, and My Unlikely Path to Truth. Near the end of the book, when Goldberg’s elderly father, who’d been operated on for colon cancer, sits down … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes | Leave a reply

Writing It Real Subscribers’ Braided Poem

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on October 14, 2004 by Jackie SedwickOctober 27, 2011

In May, I posted an article called “Coaxing Imaginative Awareness,” in which I reviewed Braided Creek: A Conversation in Poetry by Jim Harrison and Ted Kooser.  After reading the review, some Writing It Real subscribers teamed up to work on … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes | Leave a reply

The Development of a Poem by Betty Shafer

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on February 12, 2004 by Betty ShaferOctober 29, 2011

When Betty Shafer sent me the following poem for help in revising it, I read it and found something haunting stayed with me after I read the lines. Look Again We return to find our land barren Weeds choking walls … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes | Leave a reply

On the Development of the Poem “Under Cover of Green”

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on December 4, 2003 by Christine RobinsonDecember 6, 2011

Shortly after I posted the September 11, 2003 instructional exercise for Writing It Real, subscriber Christine Robinson sent me some writing of hers that resulted from using the exercise.  In this week’s article, I want to show you what she … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes | Leave a reply

Revising the Poem “A Different Christmas”

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on April 17, 2003 by Karen RippsteinOctober 29, 2011

When Karen Rippstein wrote to me that she wanted my help in shaping a poem from a prose piece she had written about a specific Christmas with her daughter, I was intrigued. Most of the people I’ve worked with bring … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes | Leave a reply

Suzan Huney’s “Choice Bits”

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on December 5, 2002 by Suzan HuneyNovember 27, 2013

At a writing conference workshop on developing the personal essay, Suzan Huney read the draft of an essay spawned by thumbing through her address book.  Her musings on the people she found in her book led to memories of her … Continue reading →

Posted in Revisions - Sample Successes, WIR2013 | Tagged on writing, revising writing, writing advice | Leave a reply

Finished Essay: “When Love is All You Have”

Sheila Bender's Writing It Real Posted on October 10, 2002 by Mary Ann PayneOctober 18, 2011

The only thing that distinguished this particular examining room from dozens like it was the huge wall chart of hearts in all manner of disease and disarray.  The rest of the room was familiar and predictable – high narrow table … Continue reading →

Posted in Archives, Revisions - Sample Successes | Leave a reply

Search Writing It Real Archives

For Recent Articles Visit sheilabender.substack.com


Archives

  • On Becoming a Writer
    August 7, 2025
  • Writing of the Body: Metaphor Making is Food for the Soul
    July 3, 2025
  • The Story of an Unlikely Writer: Philip Kenney on How Writing Changed His Life
    May 19, 2025
  • Chapter 25 from All Roads Lead to Rome, Searching for the End of My Father’s War
    May 8, 2025
  • The Long, Instructive Path to My Published Memoir
    May 1, 2025

~ View Full Article Library ~


Journal Council Member

Podcasts ~ On Air with Sheila KPTZ Radio

  • In Conversation with Charlie Fleishman
  • In Conversation With Richard Weeks
  • In Conversation with Peg Edera
  • In Conversation with Gerry McFarland
  • In Conversation with Philip Kenney
  • In Conversation with Brenda Miller
  • In Conversation with Bill Kenower
  • In Conversation with Robin Page
  • In Conversation with Sue Pace
  • In Conversation with Mindy Pollack
  • Listen to More Interviews...
  • Sheila on KUOW
©2025 - Sheila Bender's Writing It Real - Weaver Xtreme Theme
↑